Scintillator crystal, method for making same use thereof

ABSTRACT

An inorganic scintillator material, a method for growing the monocrystalline scintillator material, and the use of the scintillator material as component of a scintillating detector in particular for industrial and medical purposes and in the oil industry. The inorganic scintillator material has the general composition M 1-x Ce x Cl 3 , wherein: M is selected among lanthanides or lanthanide mixtures, preferably among the elements or mixtures of elements of the group consisting of Y, La, Gd, Lu, in particular among the elements or mixtures of elements of the group consisting of La, Gd and Lu; and x is the molar rate of substitution of M with cerium, x being not less than 1 mol% and strictly less than 100 mol%.

[0001] The present invention relates to scintillator crystals, to a manufacturing method allowing them to be obtained and to the use of said crystals, especially in gamma-ray and/or X-ray detectors.

[0002] Scintillator crystals are widely used in detectors for gamma-rays, X-rays, cosmic rays and particles whose energy is of the order of 1 keV and also greater than this value.

[0003] A scintillator crystal is a crystal which is transparent in the scintillation wavelength range, which responds to incident radiation by emitting a light pulse.

[0004] From such crystals, generally single crystals, it is possible to manufacture detectors in which the light emitted by the crystal that the detector comprises is coupled to a light-detection means and produces an electrical signal proportional to the number of light pulses received and to their intensity. Such detectors are used especially in industry for thickness or weight measurements and in the fields of nuclear medicine, physics, chemistry and oil exploration.

[0005] A family of known scintillator crystals widely used is of the thallium-doped sodium iodide Tl:NaI type. This scintillating material, discovered in 1948 by Robert Hofstadter and which forms the basis of modern scintillators, still remains the predominant material in this field in spite of almost 50 years of research on other materials. However, these crystals have a scintillation decay which is not very fast.

[0006] A material which is also used is CsI which, depending on the applications, may be used pure, or doped either with thallium (Tl) or with sodium (Na).

[0007] One family of scintillator crystals which has undergone considerable development is of the bismuth germanate (BGO) type. The crystals of the BGO family have high decay time constants, which limit the use of these crystals to low count rates.

[0008] A more recent family of scintillator crystals was developed in the 1990s and is of the cerium-activated lutetium oxyorthosilicate Ce:LSO type. However these crystals are very heterogeneous and have very high melting points (about 2200° C.).

[0009] The development of new scintillating materials for improved performance is the subject of many studies.

[0010] One of the parameters that it is desired to improve is the energy resolution.

[0011] This is because in the majority of nuclear detector applications, good energy resolution is desired. The energy resolution of a nuclear radiation detector actually determines its ability to separate radiation energies which are very close. It is usually determined for a given detector at a given energy, such as the width at mid-height of the peak in question on an energy spectrum obtained from this detector, in relation to the energy at the centroid of the peak (see in particular: G. F. Knoll, “Radiation Detection and Measurement”, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., 2nd edition, p. 114). In the rest of the text, and for all measurements carried out, the resolution is determined at 662 keV, the energy of the main gamma emission of ¹³⁷Cs.

[0012] The smaller the value of the energy resolution, the better the quality of the detector. It is considered that energy resolutions of about 7% enable good results to be obtained. Nevertheless, lower values of resolution are of great benefit.

[0013] For example, in the case of a detector used to analyze various radioactive isotopes, improved energy resolution enables improved discrimination of these isotopes.

[0014] An increase in the energy resolution is particularly advantageous for a medical imaging device, for example of the Anger gamma-camera or positron emission tomography (PET) type, since it enables the contrast and the quality of the images to be considerably improved, thus allowing more accurate and earlier detection of tumors.

[0015] Another very important parameter is the scintillation decay time constant; this parameter is usually measured by the “Start Stop” or “Multi-hit” method, (described by W. W. Moses (Nucl. Instr and Meth. A336 (1993)253).

[0016] The smallest possible decay time constant is desired, so as to be able to increase the operating frequency of the detectors. In the field of nuclear medical imaging, this makes it possible, for example, to considerably reduce the length of examinations. A decay time constant which is not very high also enables the temporal resolution of devices detecting events with temporal coincidence to be improved. This is the case for positron emission tomographs (PET), where the reduction in the scintillator decay time constant enables the images to be significantly improved by rejecting noncoincident events with more accuracy.

[0017] In general, the spectrum of scintillation decay as a function of time may be broken down into a sum of exponentials, each characterized by a decay time constant.

[0018] The quality of a scintillator is essentially determined by the properties of the contribution from the fastest emission component.

[0019] The standard scintillating materials do not allow both good energy resolutions and fast decay time constants to be obtained.

[0020] This is because materials such as Tl:NaI have good energy resolution under gamma excitation, of about 7%, but a high decay time constant of about 230 ns. Similarly, Tl:CsI and Na:CsI have high decay time constants, especially greater than 500 ns.

[0021] Decay time constants which are not very high can be obtained with Ce:LSO, especially of about 40 ns, but the energy resolution under gamma excitation at 662 keV of this material is generally greater than 10%.

[0022] Recently, scintillating materials have been disclosed by O. Guillot-Noël et al. (“Optical and scintillation properties of cerium doped LaCl₃, LuBr₃ and LuCl₃” in Journal of Luminescence 85 (1999) 21-35). This article describes the scintillation properties of cerium-doped compounds such as LaCl₃ doped with 0.57 mol % Ce; LuBr₃ doped with 0.021 mol %, 0.46 mol % and 0.76 mol % Ce; LuCl₃ doped with 0.45 mol % Ce. These scintillating materials have quite useful energy resolutions, of the order of 7%, and decay time constants of the fast scintillation component which are fairly low, especially between 25 and 50 ns. However, the intensity of the fast component of these materials is low, especially of the order of 1000 to 2000 photons per MeV, which means that they cannot be used as a component of a high-performance detector.

[0023] This object of the present application relates to a material capable of having simultaneously a good energy resolution, especially at least as good as that of Tl:NaI, a low decay time constant, especially at least equivalent to that of Ce:LSO, and where the intensity of the fast scintillation component is suitable for producing high-performance detectors, in particular is greater than 4000 ph/MeV (photons per MeV), or even greater than 8000 ph/MeV (photons per MeV).

[0024] According to the invention, this aim is achieved by an inorganic scintillating material of general composition M_(1-x)Ce_(x)Cl₃, where M is chosen from the lanthanides or mixtures of lanthanides, preferably from the elements or the mixtures of elements of the group: Y, La, Gd, Lu, especially from the elements or the mixtures of elements of the group: La, Gd, Lu, and where x is the molar level of substitution of M by cerium, subsequently called “cerium content”, where x is greater than or equal to 1 mol % and strictly less than 100 mol %.

[0025] The term “lanthanide” refers to the transition elements of atomic numbers 57 to 71, and to yttrium (Y), as is standard in the technical field of the invention.

[0026] An inorganic scintillating material according to the invention substantially consists of M_(1-x)Ce_(x)Cl₃ and may also comprise impurities usual in the technical field of the invention. In general, the usual impurities are impurities coming from the raw materials whose content is in particular less than 0.1%, or even less than 0.01%, and/or the unwanted phases whose volume percentage is especially less than 1%.

[0027] In fact, the inventors have known how to show that the M_(1-x)Ce_(x)Cl₃ compounds defined above, where the cerium content is greater than or equal to 1 mol %, have remarkable properties. The scintillation emission of the materials according to the invention has an intense fast component (of at least 4000 ph/MeV) and a low decay time constant, of the order of 25 ns. At the same time, these materials have excellent energy resolution at 662 keV, in particular less than 5%, and even than 4%.

[0028] These properties are even more remarkable since they are unexpected and highlight a considerable discontinuity of properties starting from 1 mol % of cerium. This choice of composition is even more surprising since the cerium-doped scintillators having good performance, such as LSO, contain less than 1% cerium, and preferably about 0.2% (see for example M. Kapusta et al., “Comparison of the scintillation properties of LSO:Ce manufactured by different laboratories and of LGSO:Ce”, IEEE transaction on nuclear science, Vol. 47, No. 4, August 2000).

[0029] A preferred material according to the invention has the formula La_(1-x)Ce_(x)Cl₃.

[0030] According to one embodiment, the scintillating material according to the invention has an energy resolution of less than 5%.

[0031] According to another embodiment, the scintillating material according to the invention has a fast decay time constant of less than 40 ns, or even of less than 30 ns.

[0032] According to a preferred embodiment, the scintillating material according to the invention has both an energy resolution less than 5% and a fast decay time constant of less than 40 ns, or even less than 30 ns.

[0033] In a preferred manner, the cerium content x is between 1 mol % and 90 mol %, and even in particular greater than or equal to 2 mol %, or even greater than or equal to 4 mol % and/or preferably less than or equal to 50 mol %, or even less than or equal to 30 mol %.

[0034] According to one embodiment, the scintillating material according to the invention is a single crystal making it possible to obtain components of high transparency, the dimensions of which are enough to efficiently stop and detect the radiation to be detected, including at high energy. The volume of these single crystals is in particular of the order of 10 mm³, or even greater than 1 cm³ and even greater than 10 cm³.

[0035] According to another embodiment, the scintillating material according to the invention is a powder or polycrystal, for example in the form of powders mixed with a binder or else in the form of a sol-gel.

[0036] The invention also relates to a method for obtaining the scintillating material M_(1-x)Ce_(x)Cl₃, defined above, in the form of a single crystal by the Bridgman growth method, for example in evacuated sealed quartz ampoules, in particular from a mixture of commercial MCl₃ and CeCl₃ powders.

[0037] The invention also relates to the use of the scintillating material above as a component of a detector for detecting radiation in particular by gamma rays and/or X-rays.

[0038] Such a detector especially comprises a photodetector optically coupled to the scintillator in order to produce an electrical signal in response to the emission of a light pulse produced by the scintillator.

[0039] The photodetector of the detector may in particular be a photomultiplier, or else a photodiode, or else a CCD sensor.

[0040] The preferred use of this type of detector relates to the measurement of gamma or X-ray radiation; such a system is also capable of detecting alpha and beta radiation and electrons. The invention also relates to the use of the above detector in nuclear medicine apparatuses, especially gamma cameras of the Anger type and positron emission tomography scanners (see for example C. W. E. Van Eijk, “Inorganic Scintillator for Medical Imaging”, International Seminar New types of Detectors, 15-19 May 1995—Archamp, France. Published in “Physica Medica”, Vol. XII, supplement 1, June 96).

[0041] According to another variant, the invention relates to the use of the above detector in detection apparatuses for oil drilling, (see for example “Applications of scintillation counting and analysis”, in “Photomultiplier tube, principle and application”, chapter 7, Philips).

[0042] Other details and characteristics will emerge from the description below of preferred nonlimiting embodiments and of data obtained on samples constituting single crystals according to the invention.

[0043] Table 1 shows the characteristic scintillation results for examples according to the invention (examples 1 to 5) and for comparative examples (examples A to D).

[0044] x is the cerium content, expressed in mol %, substituted into the atom M.

[0045] The measurements are carried out under γ-ray excitation at 662 keV. The measurement conditions are specified in the publication by O. Guillot-Noël, cited above.

[0046] The emission intensity is expressed in photons per MeV.

[0047] The emission intensity is recorded as a function of the integration time up to 0.5; 3 and 10 microseconds.

[0048] The fast scintillation component is characterized by its decay time constant, τ, in nanoseconds, and by its scintillation intensity (in photons/MeV), which represents the contribution of this component to the total number of photons emitted by the scintillator.

[0049] The samples used in the measurements of examples A to D and 1 to 3 and 5 are small single crystals of about 10 mm³, and the sample of example 4 is a relatively large single crystal with a diameter of 8 mm and a height of 5 mm. Good reproducibility of the results obtained was noticed between the small (ex3) and large (ex4) samples.

[0050] From table 1, it is noticed that the compounds of the M_(1-x)Ce_(x)Cl₃ type comprising less than 1 mol % cerium (examples A, D) have an energy resolution greater than 7% and low intensities of the fast scintillation component (of the order of 1500 ph/MeV). The undoped LaCl₃ has a decay time constant of the first component of about 3500 ns (exC), and is therefore extremely slow.

[0051] In the case of a fluorinated compound doped at more than 1 mol % cerium (example B), the scintillation decay is very fast but the overall scintillation efficiency is very low.

[0052] The examples according to the invention, ex1 to ex5, all have very advantageous decay time constants of the fast fluorescence component, between 20 and 30 ns, and the scintillation intensity of this fast component is remarkable and is greater that 4000 ph/MeV. It reaches about 20000 ph/MeV for a material comprising 10 mol % cerium.

[0053] In addition, the resolution, R, of these examples according to the invention is excellent and has an unexpected nature.

[0054] This is because, from the statistical point of view, it is accepted that the energy resolution varies in proportion to the inverse of the square root of the total number of photons emitted (see in particular: G. F. Knoll, “Radiation detection and measurement”, John Wiley and Sons, Inc, 2^(nd) edition, p 116). This total number of photons corresponds to the emission intensity at saturation, which is measured by the emission intensity value at 10 μs.

[0055] By considering the total number of photons emitted by LaCl₃ comprising more than 1 mol % cerium compared with LaCl₃ doped at 0.57 mol %, a small improvement of the resolution of at best 5% is expected, the latter therefore going from 7.3% to about 6.9%.

[0056] In a particularly surprising manner, the inventors noticed a considerable improvement in the energy resolution for a cerium content greater than 1 mol % in the M_(1-x)Ce_(x)Cl₃ materials. This improvement is by a factor of about 2 for LaCl₃ comprising 2 mol %, 4 mol %, 10 mol %, 30 mol % cerium (examples 1 to 5).

[0057] Scintillating materials having such a performance are particularly suitable for increasing the performance of detectors, both in terms of energy resolution, temporal resolution and count rate. TABLE 1 Emission Intensity Fast Component x: (photons/MeV) Resolution: Intensity Example Matrix mol % Ce³⁺ 0.5 μs 3 μs 10 μs (R %) τ (ns) (ph/MeV) A LuCl₃ 0.45 1300 3500 5700 18 50 1425 B LaF₃ 10 2200 2200 2200 >20 3 220 C LaCl₃ 0 34000 4.9 3480 34000 D LaCl₃ 0.57 19000 37000 44000 7.3 24 1300 ex1 LaCl₃ 2 44000 49000 3.7 27 4900 ex2 LaCl₃ 4 36000 47000 49000 3.4 25 8800 ex3 LaCl₃ 10 45000 49000 49000 3.7 26 20100 ex4 LaCl₃ 10 45000 49000 49000 3.3 26 18500 ex5 LaCl₃ 30 42000 43000 43000 3.3 24 29700 

1. An inorganic scintillating material of general composition M_(1-x)Ce_(x)Cl₃, where M is chosen from the lanthanides or mixtures of lanthanides, preferably from the elements or the mixtures of elements of the group: Y, La, Gd, Lu, especially from the elements or the mixtures of elements of the group: La, Gd, Lu, and where x is the molar level of substitution of M by cerium, where x is greater than or equal to 1 mol % and strictly less than 100 mol %.
 2. The scintillating material as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that M is lanthanum (La).
 3. The scintillating material as claimed in either one of the preceding claims, characterized in that its energy resolution is less than 6% and even than 5% for a measurement with gamma photons at 662 keV.
 4. The scintillating material as claimed in any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that x is less than or equal to 90 mol %, especially less than or equal to 50 mol %, and even less than or equal to 30 mol %.
 5. The scintillating material as claimed in any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that x is greater than or equal to 2 mol %, preferably greater than or equal to 4 mol %.
 6. The scintillating material as claimed in any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the scintillating material is a single crystal especially greater than 10 mm³, or even greater than 1 cm³.
 7. The scintillating material as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized in that the scintillating material is a powder or a polycrystal.
 8. A method of growing the single crystal scintillating material as claimed in claim 6, characterized in that the single crystal is obtained by the Bridgman growth method, in particular in evacuated sealed quartz ampoules, for example from a mixture of MCl₃ and CeCl₃ powders.
 9. The use of the scintillating material as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 7 as a component of a scintillation detector, especially for applications in industry, the medical field and/or detection for oil drilling.
 10. The use of the scintillation detector as claimed in claim 9 as the element of a positron emission tomography scanner or of a gamma camera of the Anger type. 